Xilinx 与 Altera FPGA性能比较

橄榄之家

前段时间，我用自己设计的滤波器对Xilinx和Altera的FPGA性能做了一个比较，使用的是57阶FIR滤波器, 8比特输入数据, 8比特输出数据, 13比特系数, 滤波器采用直接形式的结构, Quartus II和ISE采用默认的设计，即不加各种约束。仿真得到的一些参数如下，供大家参考。

找不到附件粘贴的方法，就没有把程序贴出来。如果有兴趣的话，也可以给我留言或者发消息，我把相应的程序发给你。

57-tap, 8 bit data in, 8 bit data out, 13 bit fixed coe, Direct structure, default compiler setting
FPGA Platform	FPGA Type	Speed (MHz)	ALUTs	Compare
Stratix II	EP2S15F484C3	218	2,085 / 12,480 ( 16 % )	114%
	EP2S15F484C4	192	2,083 / 12,480 ( 16 % )	119%
	EP2S15F484C5	162	2,084 / 12,480 ( 16 % )
Stratix	EP1S10F484C5	147	2,252 / 10,570 ( 21 % )	111%
	EP1S10F484C6	132	2,252 / 10,570 ( 21 % )	118%
	EP1S10F484C7	112	2,252 / 10,570 ( 21 % )	108%
	EP1S25F672C8	104	2,252 / 25,660 ( 8 % )
Statrix GX	EP1SGX10CF672C5	143	2,252 / 10,570 ( 21 % )
Cyclone II	EP2C8T144C6	146	1,604 / 8,256 ( 19 % )	124%
	EP2C8T144C7	118	1,609 / 8,256 ( 19 % )	122%
	EP2C8T144C8	97	1,606 / 8,256 ( 19 % )
Cyclone	EP1C3T144C6	146	2,252 / 2,910 ( 77 % )	121%
	EP1C3T144C7	121	2,252 / 2,910 ( 77 % )	111%
	EP1C3T144C8	109	2,252 / 2,910 ( 77 % )
FPGA Platform	FPGA Type	Speed (MHz)	LUTs	FFs	Slices	Compare
Virtex IV	xc4vlx15,-12	205	2,390 / 12,288 ( 19% )	1,464 / 12,288 ( 11% )	1,627 / 6,144 ( 26% )	123%
	xc4vlx15,-11	166	2,390 / 12,288 ( 19% )	1,466 / 12,288 ( 11% )	1629 / 6144 ( 26% )	111%
	xc4vlx15,-10	149	2,390 / 12,288 ( 20% )	1,466 / 12,288 ( 12% )	1628 / 6144 ( 26% )
Virtex II Pro	xc2vp2-7fg256	176	2,361 / 2,816 ( 83% )	1,442 / 2,816 ( 51% )	1,406 / 1,408 ( 99% )	117%
	xc2vp2-6fg256	150	2,378 / 2,816 ( 84% )	1,467 / 2,816 ( 52% )	1,406 / 1,408 ( 99% )	114%
	xc2vp2-5fg256	132	2,378 / 2,816 ( 84% )	1,467 / 2,816 ( 52% )	1,406 / 1,408 ( 99% )
Virtex II	xc2v500-6fg256	148	2,384 / 6,144 ( 38% )	1,461 / 6,144 ( 23% )	1,619 / 3,072 ( 52% )	123%
	xc2v500-5fg256	120	2,382 / 6,144 ( 38% )	1,461 / 6,144 ( 23% )	1,620 / 3,072 ( 52% )	115%
	xc2v500-4fg256	104	2,382 / 6,144 ( 38% )	1,461 / 6,144 ( 23% )	1,620 / 3,072 ( 52% )
Virtex	xcv600-6bg432	87	2,404 / 13,824 ( 17% )	1,465 / 13,824 ( 10% )	1,684 / 6,912 ( 24% )	113%
	xcv600-5bg432	77	2,403 / 13,824 ( 17% )	1,465 / 13,824 ( 10% )	1,684 / 6,912 ( 24% )	120%
	xcv600-4bg432	64	2,404 / 13,824 ( 17% )	1,466 / 13,824 ( 10% )	1,685 / 6,912 ( 24% )
Spartan III E	xc3s500e-5cp132	133	2,389 / 9,312 ( 25% )	1,460 / 9,312 ( 15% )	1,622 / 4,656 ( 34% )	116%
	xc3s500e-4cp132	115	2,389 / 9,312 ( 25% )	1,460 / 9,312 ( 15% )	1,622 / 4,656 ( 34% )
Spartan III	xc3s1000-5fg320	112	2,388 / 15,360 ( 15% )	1,465 / 15,360 ( 9% )	1,629 / 7,680 ( 21% )	114%
	xc3s1000-4fg320	98	2,388 / 15,360 ( 15% )	1,464 / 15,360 ( 9% )	1,629 / 7,680 ( 21% )
Spartan II E	xc2s600e-7fg456	94	2,394 / 13,824 ( 17% )	1,464 / 13,824 ( 10% )	1,688 / 6,912 ( 24% )	112%
	xc2s600e-6fg456	84